Smith’s NYC, 79 MacDougal Street, NY 10012.
May 13th, 2008 by nickI’ve developed quite a routine for each visit to New York. First an email goes out a few days prior to leaving to a few people, requesting any hot-tips, the feedback is cross-referenced against the usual sites (mainly Frank Bruni’s latest thoughts) and then the week is planned around how to make sure I get a chance to make room for a nice dinner. This week though, none of the prep was possible and I turned up on Tuesday with no plan and feeling anxious.
Why worry though, NY’ers love food and love talking food and are never short of recommendations. So, the tip I picked up for Wednesday night was Smith’s NYC in Greenwich Village. My friend Michael practically insisted we go and without reservation we turned up and managed to get two seats at the bar.
Smith’s is the result of a partnership between two NY restaurant ‘names’ – Cindy Smith of Raouls and Danny Abrams of The Mermaid Inn. They’ve managed to create a wonderfully informal yet elegant dining space. The main restaurant is smoothly designed with black leather banquettes, booths and antique mirrors. The space is long and slim and walking beyond this, you arrive at an intimate bar area, with space for 10 people to sit and eat. This is the preferred option for me – it’s quieter, the bar lady is chatty and knows her wines and it just feels right.

What also felt ‘right’ was the food. This place is something else with some very special treats that cannot be missed. It’s American cooking but with some interesting twists. We started with the Steamed Egg with Creamy Anson Mills Polenta and Gorgonzola – a joy to see as well as eat; it’s delicate, bubbling egg white dome hiding a silky and rich polenta centre. Portuguese Sardines with Parmigiano Reggiano, Tomato Confit and Olive Oil were done to perfection as well as luxurious chilled Pea and mint soup.
An entrée of Roast Lamb Saddle followed with Tomato Red Pepper Ragoñt and Parmigiano Purèe. Beautifully tender meat served medium rare with little fuss.
Smith’s must have been through its ‘the place to be’ period, as it was fortunately devoid of any pretension and aloofness amongst the diners. The staff are friendly, experienced and create a very relaxed atmosphere. A real pleasure to have been there and the first of many trips.
79 MacDougal Street
New York, NY 10012
Tel: 212.260.0100





